Tech News Today
  • Hardware
    • Motherboards
    • CPUs
    • Graphic Cards
    • RAM
    • SSDs
    • Computer Cases
    • Monitors
    • Peripherals
    • Power Supply Unit
    • PC Builds
    • Computer Tips
  • Software
  • Operating System
    • Windows
    • Mac
    • Linux
  • Gaming
  • Mobile
  • Console
  • More
    • Internet
    • Networking
    • Security
    • Buyer’s Guide
    • Gadgets
    • Laptops
    • Reviews
    • How To
    • News
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Tech News Today
  • Hardware
    • Motherboards
    • CPUs
    • Graphic Cards
    • RAM
    • SSDs
    • Computer Cases
    • Monitors
    • Peripherals
    • Power Supply Unit
    • PC Builds
    • Computer Tips
  • Software
  • Operating System
    • Windows
    • Mac
    • Linux
  • Gaming
  • Mobile
  • Console
  • More
    • Internet
    • Networking
    • Security
    • Buyer’s Guide
    • Gadgets
    • Laptops
    • Reviews
    • How To
    • News
Tech News Today
Home»Virtualization»Type 1 Vs Type 2 Hypervisor – What’s The Difference?

Type 1 Vs Type 2 Hypervisor – What’s The Difference?

Anup ThapaBy Anup ThapaAugust 24, 2022
type-1-vs-type-2-hypervisor

A hypervisor runs on a physical host and partitions the host’s resources among various virtual environments. There are two types of hypervisors.

Type 1, or bare-metal hypervisors, are installed directly on top of the physical host or server. Type 2, or hosted hypervisors, instead have an OS layer between it and the physical host.

The way Type 1 vs Type 2 hypervisors perform virtualization, the resource access and allocation, performance, and other factors differ quite a lot.

As there are certain pros and cons to both types, picking the right one for your use-cases can be difficult, but this article should give you a better understanding to that end.

Table of Contents

  • What’s a Type 1 Hypervisor?
  • What’s a Type 2 Hypervisor?
  • How Are These Two Different?
    • Virtualization Level
    • Resource Allocation
    • Performance
    • Security
    • Scalability
  • Similarities Between Type 1 & Type 2 Hypervisors
  • How Are Type 1 Hypervisors Better?
  • Should You Use Type 2 Hypervisors?
  • Final Verdict – Type 1 Vs Type 2 Hypervisor

What’s a Type 1 Hypervisor?

As shown in the figure, Type 1 Hypervisors run on top of the physical host and interact directly with the hardware, with no OS in between, as Type 1 itself acts as an OS. Thanks to this, Type 1 Hypervisors have better performance, efficiency, and security.

type-1

However, they are also more complicated to set up, use, and debug for the same reason. After all, every Type 1 is different from the other in terms of working mechanisms, meaning more hours are required to familiarize yourself with the setup and system.

Additionally, devices required to run Type 1 Hypervisors must be specifically designed for virtualization, rendering them useless for any other purpose.

Some popular Type 1 vendors include VMware ESXi, Microsoft Hyper-V, and Citrix XenServer.

Pros:
  • Direct hardware access
  • Efficient resource allocation
  • Better performance and security
  • Highly scalable
Cons:
  • Difficult to set up and maintain
  • Steep licensing costs

What’s a Type 2 Hypervisor?

On the other hand, Type 2 Hypervisors run on top of an OS layer. This makes them more prone to vulnerabilities, and the performance isn’t as good either compared to Type 1. But on the contrary, they are much easier to set up, use and troubleshoot.

type-2

Some popular Type 2 vendors include VMware Workstation Player, Oracle VM VirtualBox, and QEMU.

Pros:
  • Both affordable and completely free options available
  • Easy to set up and maintain
Cons:
  • Performance and security isn’t as great
  • Resource allocation is inefficient
  • Limited scalability
One more thing worth talking about is certain hypervisors like KVM and Hyper-V. As Hyper-V is accessible from Windows, it’s sometimes misclassified as a Type 2 hypervisor even though it’s actually Type 1.

KVM is a bit more complicated. KVM lets the Linux kernel function as a Type 1 hypervisor, but simultaneously, the overall system is categorized as a Type 2 hypervisor. The VMs themselves are implemented as normal Linux processes.

How Are These Two Different?

Here are the main differences between Type 1 vs Type 2 Hypervisors:

Virtualization Level

Type 1 Hypervisors perform virtualization at the hardware level. Usually, Ring 0 is the protection level with the most privileges as it offers direct hardware access. 

virtualization-cycle

But Intel VT-x and AMD-V insert a new ring underneath it called Ring -1, which allows the guest OS to perform Ring 0 operations without compromising anything else. This essentially means that Type 1 Hypervisors are faster and more efficient, and hardware features are directly accessible.

os-layer

On the other hand, Type 2 Hypervisors perform virtualization at the operating system level. There’s an OS layer between the hypervisor and physical host, meaning the hypervisor doesn’t have direct hardware access.

Instead, the kernel creates isolated user spaces where the guest OS runs, similar to any other application or process. This means Type 2 hypervisors run at Ring 1 or higher.

Resource Allocation

Type 1 Hypervisors assign resources dynamically. For instance, let’s say you have a server with 64 GBs of memory and 6 virtual servers running on it. If you want to assign 16 GBs or more to each server, you can safely do so even though the total would technically come out higher than what should be possible.

In a real-world scenario, it’s highly unlikely that all the virtual servers will max out their memory usage simultaneously.

In the case of Type 2 hypervisors, the virtual servers occupy all of the assigned resources even if they don’t actually need them.

Performance

As stated, Type 1 hypervisors run directly on top of the host with no middleman, which translates into better performance.

performace

Contrasting this, Type 2 hypervisors run on top of an OS layer. The guest OS is dependent on the host OS for access to resources, which results in higher latency.

Security

Although extremely rare, there’s always the possibility of hyperjacking, regardless of the hypervisor type. But barring this minor possibility, Type 1 Hypervisors are very secure.

security

Type 2 hypervisors, on the other hand, are not as reliable. Any problems with the underlying host OS, from malware and hacking to crashes, can affect the performance of the VMs.

Scalability

Considering the various factors we’ve detailed so far, from resource allocation and efficiency to performance and security, it should come as no surprise that Type 1 hypervisors are vastly more popular in enterprise environments.

Type 2 hypervisors, which have to rely on the underlying OS, have comparatively limited scalability. They are better suited for personal use or certain environments where devs need to test and use various operating systems.

Similarities Between Type 1 & Type 2 Hypervisors

The prime similarity between Type 1 and Type 2 hypervisors is that they can both make use of hardware-assisted virtualization. Compared to software virtualization, where the hypervisor handles everything independently, modern processors can assist hypervisors with virtualization to maximize performance and minimize overhead.

How Are Type 1 Hypervisors Better?

As we’ve detailed in the sections above, Type 1 Hypervisors are better in terms of most metrics, from security, performance, and scalability, to resource access and allocation.

As such, they are commonly used in large server environments such as data centers or enterprises.

Should You Use Type 2 Hypervisors?

While Type 1 Hypervisors are better if we go by the raw specs, Type 2 Hypervisors are better options in certain scenarios.

For starters, Type 2 Hypervisors are simpler to set up and use. They are also typically affordable or entirely free. This is not the case with Type 1 Hypervisors, where the licensing costs are quite high, and in the cases of free options, the functionality is limited.

This makes Type 2 Hypervisors better suited for personal use. After all, it doesn’t make sense to purchase expensive Type 1 licenses just to set up a couple of operating systems in your home lab.

The same reasoning is true for certain professional environments as well. Tech professionals often need access to different operating systems for testing on different platforms. In such cases, Type 2 Hypervisors are a popular solution. 

Final Verdict – Type 1 Vs Type 2 Hypervisor

Type 1 hypervisors can seem better on paper, but there are real-world applications for both hypervisor types. The right one for you will depend on your specific needs and use cases, as we’ve detailed in this article. Finally, to recap, here are the key differences between Type 1 and Type 2 Hypervisors:

Type 1Type 2
Virtualization LevelVirtualization occurs on the hardware level (Ring 0).Virtualization occurs on the OS level (Ring 1 or higher).
Resource AccessDirect access to hardware features.Requests have to be directed to the host OS first.
Resource AllocationSupports dynamic resource allocation.Resource allocation is not as efficient.
PerformanceBetter performance.Comparatively worse performance.
SecurityMore secure.Not as secure.
ScalabilityBetter scalability.Not as scalable.
ExamplesVMware ESXi
Microsoft Hyper-V
Citrix XenServer
VMware Workstation Player
Oracle VirtualBox
QEMU
X Vs. Y
Anup Thapa
  • LinkedIn

Anup Thapa is a tech writer at TechNewsToday. He mostly writes informative articles, tutorials, and troubleshooting guides related to Windows systems, networking, and computer hardware. Anup has been writing professionally for almost 5 years, and tinkering with PCs for much longer. His love for all things tech started when he got his first PC over 15 years ago. It was a Pentium IV system running Windows XP on a single 256 MB stick. He spent his formative years glued to this PC, troubleshooting any hardware or software problems he encountered by himself. Professionally, Anup has had brief forays into a variety of fields like coding, hardware installation, writing, etc. In doing so, he's worked with people of different backgrounds and skill levels, from average joes to industry leaders and experts. This has given him not just a versatile skillset, but also a unique perspective for writing that enables him to concisely communicate complex information and solve his reader's problems efficiently. You can contact him at anup@technewstoday.com

Related Posts

virtual machine disks consolidation is needed

4 Ways to Fix “Virtual Machine Disks Consolidation is Needed”

December 27, 2022
virtualbox shared folder

How to Create Shared Folder on Virtualbox

November 29, 2022
failed to open a session for the virtual machine

How to Fix “Failed to Open a Session For The Virtual Machine” Error?

September 30, 2022
how to uninstall virtualbox

How to Uninstall VirtualBox on Windows

September 28, 2022
how to use vmware

How to Use VMware (Detailed Guide)

September 23, 2022
virtualize a physical machine vmware

How To Virtualize A Physical Machine With VMware

September 17, 2022
Add A Comment

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Latest Posts
sata ports on motherboard

All the Types of SATA Ports on Motherboard

March 21, 2023
anti-aliasing-on-or-off

What is Anti Aliasing? Should You Turn It on or off

March 21, 2023
APU vs CPU

APU Vs CPU – What’s the Difference?

March 19, 2023
You may also like
how-to-print-from-iphone

How to Print From iPhone? Step-by-Step Guide

March 22, 2023
ctrl key not working

Why is My Ctrl Key Not Working? 7 Ways to Fix It

March 21, 2023
how-to-scan-a-document-on-hp-printer

How to Scan a Document on HP Printer

March 21, 2023
Recommended
Cookie Clicker Garden Guide

Cookie Clicker Garden Guide to Unlocking Every Seed

September 26, 2021
monitor no signal

Computer Turns On But Monitor Says No Signal (9 Ways To Fix)

November 10, 2022
Facebook Twitter Pinterest
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Privacy Policy
  • Affiliate Disclosure
© 2023 TechNewsToday, editor@technewstoday.com | Tech Central Pvt. Ltd.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.